Broadway Bob’s

Theater Reviews

By Bob Massimi
The Ask

THE ASK

“The Ask” at Theater 555 falters in so many ways. It is too slow, too slipshod in its writing and the direction while even paced, never lends itself to the play.

Written by Matthew Freeman and directed by Jessi D.Hill, the play runs laps and never goes anywhere. It tries to be this political awakening about the ACLU, however, it simply falls flat on many fronts.

Actors Marilu Henner (Greta) and Shannon Purser (Tanner) never give us any emotion. Henner plays a wealthy, self important woman who either married money, came from money or made her own money. We are never sure where her money came from. All we know about her is that she is this rich liberal woman who thinks that she is important and that her opinion is the only one. She talks at Tanner and not to her.Greta is not liked at all, so much so that the audience seemed to be wandering rather than listening to her.

Equally ineffective, Purser has really no redeeming qualities. She is essentially begging Greta for money, but when Greta pressures her for answers about the ACLU, she has no concrete answers as to how the ACLU works now-a-days. In the direction of the play, Tanner starts to cry for no good reason leaving the audience looking at one another wondering where the play is going.

The one good thing that works for the show is D. Craig M. Napoliello’s set design. He captures the New York Apartment well. Where the lighting leaves the audience seeing halos around the two actors, the costumes by Nicole Wee are passable.

This 90 minute intermissionless play is steeped in liberal politics. Some of the dialogue will have you rolling your eyes. This play is almost an homage to Freeman’s political beliefs. Freeman uses the body of work tied up in the ACLU and all that it believes in as well as the history of the organization. In its infancy, the actors get tongue tied in their deliveries at times.

Even for the liberal minded people who may want to see this show, the writing is never concrete, never meaningful for the audience. Tanner never hits back at Greta who carries a lot of monetary weight. We never know what Tanner even stands for other than her wanting money from Greta. When Greta questions why the ACLU does things the way they do, Tanner never has an answer. This eliminates the good dialogue that could have been. Here, we only get dribes and drabes of banter that are meaningless.


Waiting For Lefty

WAITING FOR LEFTY

This is the year of the lefty! Clifford Odets will have not one, but two shows in New York City this year: “Waiting For Lefty” which is playing at the CSC in the East Village and “Awake and Sing” to play Broadway in the next two months. And if that is not enough Agitprop theater (agitation and propaganda), Eugene Ionesco’s “Rhinoceros” starring the great John Turturro will play April 2027.

When the play started and an actress handed me a flyer disparaging Elon Musk becoming a trillionaire, I thought I was headed for a long night. When I handed it back, the person next to me asked me if I liked Musk. Even still looking at the audience, it seemed that I was caught in a time warp of 1960’s beatniks. Even still, a good journalist puts his politics aside and gives the show a fair shake regardless.

The direction under Steven Paquale is raw and creative. His insightfulness into this classic is first rate. For one hour and fifteen minutes, the audience is locked in tight to this 1935 period piece that takes place in The Bronx, New York. While Odets paints a story with a wide brush, Pasquale fine tunes the story with passionate actors and folksy musicians.

The episodes are placed on a beam to let the audience know what scene is playing out. We are given the many problems that the characters face. Whether it is marital problems through financial issues, health problems, or decisions that some are not willing to face. Odets brings the time and the issues to the forefront for everyone to chew on. He also brings corruption to the forefront, and not just the owners, but the union leaders themselves. To the writer, no one is innocent here; but everyone of the characters are desperate. Most of the characters will do anything to get out from under. Edna, who is married to Joe, is willing to leave him and go back to her old boyfriend. Flore is told by Herb that he cannot afford to marry her after being engaged for three years.

“Waiting For Lefty” at the Classic Stage Company is well done; both the acting and direction makes this Greenwich Village play exciting to watch.


Much Ado About Nothing

MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING

Like “Six”; “&Juliet”, “Much Ado About Nothing” at the Winter Garden Theatre is smaltzie, slapstickish, and great entertainment for teenagers and older.

Tom Hiddkeston As Benedick and Hayley Atwell as Beatrice reprise their West End roles. Both campy and aloof, the two bring a winner to the Winter Garden.

The traditional theater lover, like “A Dolls House”, probably will not like this show. For starters, scenic designer Soutra Gilmour has the stage in thick pink paper, it almost looks like the insulation used in houses. Jon Clark’s lighting adds to the glam part of the show. Clark’s lighting helps to keep the audience in a campy mood in this two and a half hour musical. Actors breakout modern songs intermittently which has no barring on the show whatsoever. This was an audience favorite.

James Phoon (Claudio), and Mara Huf ( Hero) work as well together as Hiddleston and Atwell do. While the later banter more, the former are more artistic and devout to the Shakespearian role. This comes front and center under the direction by Jamie Lloyd. Lloyd gets credit for this carnival like show.

Broadway over the last several years has developed musicals like “Much Ado”. The show is lite, fun, campy and entertaining. Much like “Back To The Future” which played in this theater a few years ago, this show too has something for everybody. From the dancing in the isles before the show and at intermission, to Hiddleston hamming it up for the audience, “ Much Ado About Nothing” may very well be the show of the year!

In the shows fast pace, Choreographer Fabian Aloise gets credit for the unique style set forth in the show. Sometimes simple; other times more contrived, Aloise is brilliant here.

Walking out of the theater I wondered what The Bard would think of this musical. As a writer who had comedic undercurrent, I’m sure he would have been amused!