The Baker House 1650 Wins Again

Back-to-Back Honors in East Hampton

By Clara Morgan

The Baker House 1650 has won its second consecutive Condé Nast Johansens Award for Excellence. The East Hampton Village hotel, owned by Antonella Bertello, was named Best House, Villa or Residence for 2027 in the guide’s North America division, which covers the United States and the Caribbean. The award was announced November 2 at the Montcalm Mayfair in London.

The win follows the property’s 2026 award for Best House, Villa or Serviced Apartment in the same region. The guide’s annual awards draw on guest reviews, public votes and assessments by its local experts. For Bertello, the second win recognizes the team that helps give the hotel the atmosphere of a private home.

“We have always wanted our guests to feel that they are staying in a beautiful private home rather than a conventional hotel,” Bertello said in the award announcement. She credited her staff with preserving that atmosphere while maintaining the personal service she envisioned for the property.

AN ENGLISH MANOR ON MAIN STREET
At 181 Main Street, the property dates to 1650 and takes its architectural cues from England’s Cotswolds. Exposed beams, period furnishings and fireplaces give the main house its country manor character. The rooms are individually furnished, and many have wood-burning fireplaces and whirlpool tubs. Outside, English gardens, terraces and pools provide places to spend time on the grounds within walking distance of East Hampton Village shops and restaurants.

The carriage house sits behind the main house on its own landscaped acre. Its Loft suite has a private entrance, a separate living room and a terrace furnished with teak lounge chairs. The ground-floor Lily Pond room has a fireplace and a sitting area. The two buildings give guests a choice between staying in the historic main house and settling into quieter quarters farther back from Main Street.

Guests can also reserve the Baker Spa for private use. Its facilities include a heated indoor pool, sauna, steam shower and soaking tub. In summer, the hotel provides village beach parking passes and lends guests chairs, umbrellas and towels. In cooler weather, the fireplaces and spa offer reasons to linger at the property after a day in the village.

A Place in Village Life
Bertello, who was born in Lima, Peru, brings a background in real estate, design and interiors to the hotel. Her work has taken her from East Hampton to South Florida and Latin America. At the Baker House, she has made room for private celebrations and receptions alongside overnight stays, bringing local arts and philanthropic groups into a property that otherwise feels tucked away.

That local role was on display during the Hamptons International Film Festival season, when Bertello and philanthropist Jean Shafiroff hosted an autumn reception at the hotel. Bertello’s community work has also included support for Guild Hall and the Animal Rescue Fund of the Hamptons. For visitors, the address puts those village institutions within reach of a stay that can be built around the gardens, the spa or a walk down Main Street.

The Baker House 1650 www.bakerhouse1650.com
Condé Nast Johansens awards www.johansens.com/awards
IG @bakerhouse1650 | FB thebakerhouse1650 | X @thebakerhouse
Photo credits @mixmediaplus, Daniel Dottavio